Commentary: Still reeling from Dutertes war on drugs, Manilas poor hit hardest by COVID-19

Your ads will be inserted here by

Easy Plugin for AdSense.

Please go to the plugin admin page to
Paste your ad code OR
Suppress this ad slot.

NEW YORK CITY: Flaviano Villanueva was in tears last Thursday. It was day five of the “enhanced community quarantine” in Metro Manila, where the priest runs a homeless centre.

The sprawling Philippine capital of 13 million people had been sealed off, and police and army troopers were guarding municipal boundaries to prevent entry and exit. Businesses were shuttered, and public transport was scarce.



Early that morning, dozens of homeless people lined up on the street outside the Kalinga (Care) Centre, waiting for the doors to open. They stood 1.5 metres apart, in line with the governments guidance for the quarantine at that time.

But the head of the barangay, or village council, who had not been happy having the centre there, ordered it shut and drove the homeless away.

“The barangay captain said they were just following the law, no mass gatherings,” Villanueva said. “But the first law is to save lives. These are among the first people who are going to die.”

READ: Commentary: Three scenarios if the COVID-19 outbreak gets worse



READ: Commentary: COVID-19 self-isolation is punishing the poor in Indonesia


Manila, as in many other places, the COVID-19 pandemic is hitting the poor the hardest and exposing the gaping inequities in access to food, shelter, and health care.

On Mar 15, after a surge of new COVID-19 cases, President Rodrigo Duterte declared a month-long quarantine in the capital. He also mandated an 8pm to 5am curfew, deployed the police and the army to man checkpoints, and ordered the arrest of those who violated the law.

Two days later, the quarantine was expanded to include the whole island of Luzon, home to 60 million people.

LISTEN: What's behind the different approaches countries are taking towards COVID-19?

Pedestrians wearing protective masks, following an outbreak of coronavirus disease (COVID-19), walk on an overpass in Manila, Philippines, March 12, 2020. REUTERS/Eloisa Lopez

Whether fighting crime, tamping down extremism, or battling a pandemic, Duterte rules with a heavy hand, and with little care for the consequences. His repertoire is narrow – the iron fist, not the velvet glove.

To be sure, few disagree that restrictions are needed to deal with the pandemic.

But they took the country by surprise. With little warning, millions who eke out a hardscrabble existence in the citys underground economy were left without any means of support as businesses closed and people were ordered off the streets.

The government focused on enforcing the quarantine; little thought was given to mitigating its impact on the most vulnerable. While cops and soldiers were out on the streets, social workers were told to stay home.

READ: Commentary: Dont forget the vulnerable in the fight against COVID-19

Your ads will be inserted here by

Easy Plugin for AdSense.

Please go to the plugin admin page to
Paste your ad code OR
Suppress this ad slot.

Its classic Duterte. On day one of his presidency in 2016, he ordered the police to conduct raids that killed thousands of suspected drug users and sellers in the shantytowns in Manila and other big cities. Little heed was paid to drug rehabilitation or to alleviating the misery and joblessness that drove the poor to the drug trade.

In 2017, the Armys siege of the southern city of Marawi, then held by Islamic militants, killed nearly 1200 and displaced more than 350,000. Today, thousands are still in unsanitary refugee camps as government efforts to rebuild the ravaged city have sputtered.

READ: Commentary: Why support for the Islamic State has persisted in Southeast Asia


Back in Manila, the pandemic threatens to break the already frayed fabric of families and communities that had not yet recovered from the war on drugs.

Danny Pilario is a priest who has been ministering to the poor near the Payatas garbage dump in the northern part of the capital. Last week, he was busy trying to organise food and supplies for the widows of drug war victims and their neighbours.

Payatas is in the “red zone”, as there was a COVID-19 outbreak nearby. Policemen and village watchmen were manning checkpoints there, and only those with a quarantine pass were allowed in, making it difficult for non-residents to bring in supplies. Pilario sent money instead, so the families could buy rice and other goods in the markets nearby.

Pilario hopes he can keep these subsidies going. Even in the best of times, he said, the poor of Payatas earned barely enough for three meals. Now unable to work, they had no savings to tide them over. Many had already lost breadwinners to the anti-drug campaign.

READ: Commentary: The good, the bad and the ugly of Rodrigo Dutertes war on drugs

A mother grieves for her dead son, a victim of the war on drugs, in Manila last October AFP/NOEL CELIS

READ: Commentary: The Philippines, home of many beautiful destinations – and the scourge of mass tourism

Manilas poor live in crowded settlements near government offices, shopping malls, or wealthy gated enclaves, yet they receive scant attention and support. When the drug war started, many Filipinos were oblivious to the carnage.

Pilario said he found out about the killings only because of the stench of a rotting corpse in a shanty near the chapel where he said mass. The family did not have enough money to bury the dead man who had been lying in a wooden casket for weeks.

Those who work among the poor fear the havoc the coronavirus will likely wreak in Manilas shantytowns. Many there dont have running water, said Pilario. How can they even wash their hands? They can barely afford to eat, much less buy hand sanitisers.

Shacks no bigger than a flatbed truck house large families whose members sleep side-by-side on wooden or cement floors. In the slums, where people are packed like bees in a hive, there is no such thing as social distancing.

READ: Its not that I want to sell my kid. I just need money: The Philippine mothers who sell their babies

READ: Why in a cheap food paradise, some Singaporeans are still going hungry


For now, theres a patchwork of efforts by local governments, churches, civic groups, and ordinary citizens trying to do what they can.

Companies are donating food and supplies. An actress has called for donations for street vendors who can no longer peddle their wares.

A restaurant has opened its doors to the homeless, as have some churches and Catholic schools. Many groups are organising donations, braving checkpoints, and overcoming government limits on food purchases to helpRead More – Source